Oprah’s Academy: Salvation or Vanity?
Tuesday, February 24th, 2009Speaking of the importance of recognizing gender differences, as Makhete discussed in the below post, Oprah’s South African school has drawn much attention since its opening a few years ago–both positive and negative. Aside from the recent scandal, the concept of the school has been both scrutinized and praised since its inception.
The school, a $40 million private boarding center featuring state of the art facilities including yoga and art studios, has been a blessing from an educational standpoint, says Gene Sperling, director of the Center for Universal Education at the Council on Foreign Relations. Sperling is quoted in a Christian Science Monitor article as saying:
“I think it’s very important for people to recognize that the lack of education for both boys and girls is a crisis in Africa…But the benefits of girls’ education, in terms of improving health, women’s empowerment, and family well-being, probably does make girls’ education the highest-returning social investment in the world.”
Similarly, there is published research that dictates the benefit of improving education for girls, as it increases per capita income and improves female health, lowers fertility rates and HIV, as well as infant mortality. In other words, when women are educated, they are less likely to contract disease or get pregnant, and they are more likely to contribute positively to the workforce and provide for their children.
Statistically, less than half of southern African girls remain in school. Because of extreme poverty and disease, many are forced to drop out before reaching the secondary level to take care of their families, and contribute to the family income.
While Oprah has no doubt recognized in a positive way the need for long-term funding to support girls’ education across South Africa, she has been criticized for instituting such a high-profile, exclusive school and I can’t help but agree. Forty million dollars could have gone a lot farther than 50 acres, and it seems the money could have been used to build some sort of educational system or series of schools that would benefit many more girls. It could have also been used to improve existing schools across the country.
It can be argued that the school is too exclusive and advanced for the needs of the world that these girls will be returning to after they graduate. These girls are coming from the poorest of the poorest areas of South Africa. How will they really benefit from knowing yoga poses? Will art classes really provide viable life and work skills these girls need to support themselves and their families?